NLOTH / BEST: Best, Worst, Underrated

.

Cedars, easily.

Moment Of Surrender is a top three U2 song for me so it wins, but there's some good competition here. Unknown Caller and Fez are also among U2's very finest output IMO.

I picked Fez. Shoutout to MOS and Cedars.

MOS.

Arguably their finest song of the past 20 years.

I picked Fez. Shoutout to MOS and Cedars.

Same, reminds me of Boomerang 2.

Magnificent beating MOS by a narrow margin. 

I always enjoyed the beach clip of it that leaked. 

MOS. However, like the strings on U2’s AIWIY and the Pavarotti cameo of Miss Sarajevo, the stadium singalong bit at the end should have been dropped.

MOS.

Arguably their finest song of the past 20 years.

Easily.  And i do quite like Magnificent and Cedars as well.  Overall a good album save for the middle 3 disaster.

Fez. The only great song on the album.

I like Magnificent just fine and MoS is ok I guess although I find it clunky. The rest I would rate from boring to terrible. Cedars gets my vote for most overrated song on this forum. 

Winter is OVERRATED. A song so boring, watching grass grow is more interesting.

Magnificent beating MOS by a narrow margin. 

I always enjoyed the beach clip of it that leaked.

Yeah it was listening to this track on the night of the leak that got me excited for this album. I remember hearing that its working title was "French Disco," and it definitely had that feel when I first heard it. I know this song gets a bad rap, but I love it and think it's a top-3 track on NLOTH.

Winter is OVERRATED. A song so boring, watching grass grow is more interesting.

Yeah it is kind of boring. I used to think it should have been included on NLOTH, but it’s really no better than the average filler track from Bomb. Not terrible, but not amazing.

I hate those forced keyboard fills in Magnificent. Completely ruins the song for me.

Moment of Surrender.

Lots of songs I like on this album but this one stands out as perfect for me.