A very honest review, an tha. I actually expected most of this...knowing you as I seem to.
And, you're right, it's far from their best album, but I'm liking (loving) it more each day. I'm even warming up to American Soul (a bit). So, give AS another chance, or two. And, I disagree with you 100% on Love Is Bigger...but, that's probably a personal thing with me. But, as I told OnlyU2 the other day, I was REALLY apprehensive about this album the first time I listened...wasn't sure I was going to like it (WHAT? Riffy not like a U2 album?) But, I'm slowly falling head-over-heels. No, it's not AB or Pop, or UF. It probably won't be in too many fan's top five fav albums. But, it's beautiful. I do like the connections to SOI a lot. But, I'd like more depth, more darkness, and more raucous rock & roll. I'd like more Edge (turn it up!). Adam absolutely owns this album. And, I think Bono sounds wonderful. Larry is always great.
HEY - this is about YOUR review, not mine! oops...sorry...I got carried away. anyway, I did enjoy reading your review...thanks for not putting it out there after your first listen!