It's funny ... this song is not one that sticks in my mind, I actually had to put it on to remind myself what it's like. I liked it! I think if it had come on the radio and I didn't realize it was U2, I would have enjoyed listening to it, which is pretty much how I evaluate most songs. :-)
But since it is U2 ... so many songs I like better, I suspect they crowd it out of my mind. So ... better than a meh, but not quite a yay.
I do think they could have dropped the brass, but I've never been a big fan of that particular type of horn sound.