I'll share my picks so y'all can judge me.
Numb
My #1. It's cool, it's interesting, memorable, looks great, meaningful and related to the song, good lip synching. By the way, goid lip synching is important to me in a music video and unfortunately Bono sucks at it.
Sweetest Thing
I just think it works well, the premise and execution and it's fun to watch.
Beautiful Day
It's cool and fun and the plane shit rocks.
Vertigo
Yeah, a song off my most hated album made my list. It's about what I like in a music video. I think the band looks reasonably cool, there is a visual hook, it's fun to watch, it's related to the meaning of the song without being overly obvious. The lip synching is okay, which is the best it gets for Bono.
Sometimes You Can't...
And it's TWO off my most hated album! The only one in my top five that is serious and not playful. It just kind of hit the sentiment of the song pretty well.
Honorable mentions
Found
I find this period of videos so obnoxious but Obnoxious Bono singing into Annoyed Edge's ear seems pretty meta so I'm kinda down for it.
One
It works.
Mysterious Ways
Almost a home run. Jesus, Bono, I know you can't dance but at least stand up straight? He's graceful so can't he just, like, move cool or whatever? He pulls it off onstage just fine.
Stay
Really really good. I guess I'm a basic bitch about lip synching on videos though. Gimme something to work with. The statue thing is awesome, drag is awesome.
Discotheque
I'm the opposite of everyone else; the Villiage People part is the ONLY giod part. The staging is awesome but I need more band members being cool. We get only glimpses. Also, I know you guys can't dance, but surely you can have a couple of choreographed moves? Okay, you did ONE move. MORE.
Please
Almost made my top five. Probably it should have but I just enjoy the others a little better. Absurd, ridiculous - just like it should be.
Finally, I checked out Crazy Tonight. My eyes are really bad so I couldn't follow the storyline. The animation style was compelling, it might be good.
And nobody nominated Song fir Someone, but Woody did good work and the filmmaker and camera operator did good work. There's really good stuff there.