PJ peaked with Vs.
You haven't heard Gigaton yet.
Duh. Because it's not out.
I can only judge them on their body of work to date.
They peaked with Vs.
The point was that you might change your mind about them peaking with Vs after Gigaton is released.
Never say never in anything but how many bands release records that create a new high mark for them 30 years into their careers and when they are nearly 60?
My guess would be very, very few....
Well, what determines whether or not an artist has achieved a new high mark?
01. Individuals opinions of the album, but this will vary from person to person.
02. Music journalist, critics, awards etc.
03. Level of popularity based on sales, airplay, streaming etc.
Musicianship or Art is not like athletic performance for Olympic caliber athletes, which tends to peak in ones younger years. In fact, it could be argued that Musicianship and Art get better with age.