Pretty similar take here.
Miracle - was an early favorite but burned out. I think it's just a very "easy" song, so it doesn't take getting used to. I never say, hey, I wanna listen to The Miracle. But if it's on, I'm perfectly happy. Usually start album play with EBW.
California - unlike most of you, it's not a skip for me. It was, however, the very LAST song on the album that I adopted. I love it. Loathed it at first.
SFS - same as Miracle, liked it early but moved on. It's a skip, but if I do play it, I'm perfectly happy.
Volcano - not usually a skip but not a top fave. Like AS way more. Like Volcano just fine.
Everything else on SOI is a gem to me.
Best Thing - skip. I will not die if forced to listen, but I have no idea why they made this a single. Jaysus.
GOOYOW/AS - screw all of you; I love em, I don't skip.
Showman - usually but not always a skip, do like it fine though.
13 - love the verses, loathe the chorus. I can't rectify this song. I want a do-over. It's different from Miracle of Showman, it's not a "pleasantly like but don't love." It's a love and a hate.
I will say that SOI and SOE don't have any songs that I loathe. This is different from NLOTH (loathe Boots, didn't get into SUC enough to even know it), HTDAAB (loathe most of the album), or ATYCLB (loathe the last third). IE's weakest songs for me, I'd still get at least some enjoyment out of. Grace, for example, I'D RATHER HAVE SILENCE THAN LISTEN TO IT.