First two proper albums are indeed great as mentioned. They started out as a hippie/hipster outfit with arena alt-rock vibe, then went Springsteen on Neon Bible (their most accessible record I think). I never listened to the Suburbs in full, but I actually liked Reflektor a lot. They went from U2-Springsteen musical stylings to Talking Heads, and it worked. I haven't heard the new album yet, but the disco/electronic first single was a bit too on the nose, too calculated.
Anyone care to compare their new album to the old ones?