Rate a song: WITH OR WITHOUT YOU

10

God didn't just walk through the room,  he sat down and listened to the recording,  then stood up and applauded once it was finished.

You are really cracking me up! And, at the same time...saying everything I think!

Quote from: Amor fati on March 12, 2018, 07:31:05 PM

10

God didn't just walk through the room,  he sat down and listened to the recording,  then stood up and applauded once it was finished.

You are really cracking me up! And, at the same time...saying everything I think!

 

Live would probably be a 10, I give Studio a 9.5.

I know I'm in the minority on this one.  When it first came out, it was really the only song on JT I did not enjoy, I felt it was a title too smarmy and wimpy so it never realy took.  Oddly, I enjoy much more its counterpart AIWIY.

Anyway, it has grown a bit on me over the years and I can see beyond what I first thought of it.  Still not a big favorite of mine, but did give it an 8.

Oh thank God, I thought I'd be the only one. I feel guilty about it, but this song has never connected with me. I've tried, honest, but ... just can't get there. Gave it a ... ahem ... 6. (Ducks behind shield.)